Oops. I goofed -- Time Alignment vs. Phase Coherence


I goofed yesterday and I feel very embarrassed about it.

I was editing my Take Three email "3 most common Phase myths" in two different tabs, and I hit SEND on the wrong tab, so the last point I was making was completely missing from the email. 😂

I'll finish my thought below. The bright side is, now you know for sure these emails aren't written by AI!

Myth #3: "Time alignment = phase coherence"

​I totally understand the temptation to think this way. We try to manually align capsules of microphones to achieve maximum phase coherence. Why wouldn't we also do that in our DAW?

The reason goes back to complex waveforms and correlation, or "sameness" between different signals.

A close mic on a snare drum is poorly correlated to a distant room mic. Aligning those two signals in the time domain usually does nothing for their coherence, and it often causes more problems.

This is honestly the biggest frustration I have with Auto Align and why I decided to make PhaseLock. The way it works in 4 steps:

1. PhaseLock slices up the audio, creates a distribution of the coherence, and builds a "tree" hierarchy of correlated signals from the main reference, all the way down to every instance in your group.

2. It asks you "do you want to do any time alignment?" And if so, you can choose to align ANY track to ANY other track, unlike Auto Align. Sometimes useful for highly correlated signals, a DI + amp combo, or dialog.

3. It then determines "should polarity be inverted?" or more precisely, "are these signals pretty much inverted right now?" And if so, it inverts automatically.

4. It then asks "what is the optimal arrangement of all pass filters across every track in this group to achieve maximum coherence at the most important frequencies between them?" and applies those automatically. This is the one that gives the "wow" moment.

I've been learning and obsessing over the science behind phase relationships for the last year, and I cannot wait to let this work out into the wild.

If you read this far, I really appreciate you, Reader. Sorry for the double email this week.

Until Wednesday, happy music making!

Thomas Dulin

Producer / Engineer / Mixer

Take Three

Get my free weekly 3 minute email. Read by songwriters, artists, producers, and audio engineers to make better records.

Read more from Take Three

Three minute reads for audio engineers and music makers By Thomas Dulin Hey Reader, here's this week's Take Three email. TAKE ONE: QUICK LINKS I enjoyed this article, "Should Audio Professionals Advertise Their Rates?" by Russ Hughes Sony and Warner Chappell have sued Anthropic, via Variety Reason software is now available as a free plugin in your DAW, it's called Reason Free. TAKE TWO: PHASELOCK UPDATE Over the last week I've solved two problems with PhaseLock: one specific to Fender Studio...

Three minute reads for audio engineers and music makers By Thomas Dulin Hey Reader, hope you're having a great week. Here's this week's Take Three email. PhaseLock Beta folks! This is my weekly email. Friendly reminder that if you don't want to receive Take Three emails, no hard feelings. Opt out here to stay in the beta. If you just "unsubscribe" you'll kick yourself out of the beta. TAKE ONE: QUICK LINKS Free Tube Saturation Plugins Worth Having In 2026, via Production Expert Bonnaroo Is...

Three minute reads for audio engineers and music makers By Thomas Dulin Hey Reader, here's this week's Take Three email. Quick reminder. If you're part of the PhaseLock beta and you do not want to receive my awesome weekly emails, you can opt out of these here. TAKE ONE: QUICK LINKS UAD's Moog Model D synth is 80% off ($29) if you buy it through Plugin Boutique. Why Your USB Hub Could Be Corrupting Your Studio Drives, via Production Expert MusicTech's "best new plugins, free and paid" this...